Eliminating off-roading and taking advantage of the available traction are the core components of off-roading. You see, aftermarket modifications directed towards off-roading are designed to generate greater traction or improve the automobile’s prowess at conquering obstacles.
A locking differential, however, is truly a fixture of the off-roading world and not the only one. However, the Electric Lockers vs. Air Lockers argument pertaining to the offroad community is whether Airlockers are better than E-Lockers.
Both choices have strong benefits and drawbacks and are worthy of consideration. If you have also found yourself in this chaos, let’s get you out.
Electric Lockers Vs Air Lockers In A Table
Here’s a table comparing Electric Lockers and Air Lockers:
| Feature | Electric Lockers | Air Lockers |
|---|---|---|
| Activation Method | Activated electrically via a switch. | Activated by compressed air from an onboard air compressor. |
| Complexity of System | Relatively simpler system. | Engagement time can vary depending on the air system. |
| Installation | Generally simpler to install. | Requires additional air system installation. |
| Response Time | Usually offers quicker engagement. | Dependent on the reliability of the air system. |
| Durability | Fewer moving parts, potentially more durable. | Dependent on the reliability of air system. |
| Maintenance | Lower maintenance due to fewer components. | Requires maintenance of air compressor and lines. |
| Operational Reliability | Less affected by environmental factors. | Can be affected by air system leaks or failures. |
| Cost | Can be more cost-effective initially. | Higher initial cost due to air system components. |
| Versatility | Suitable for a variety of off-road conditions. | Highly effective in extreme off-road conditions. |
| Noise | Typically quieter operation. | May produce noise from the air compressor. |
| Power Source Dependency | More complex, and requires an air compressor. | Relies on an external air source (compressor). |
| Popularity | Common in factory-equipped off-road vehicles. | Favored by hardcore off-roaders and professionals. |
What Is An Electronic Locking Differential?
The electronic locking differential is an apparatus in the rear of a vehicle for secure synchronization of both rear wheels. The electronic differential device adds useful traction when your vehicle is stuck. You can set the differential automatically within the operating speed range, and you can use the electronic differential within the operating speed range.
When you exceed a set speed, the electronic differential disengages for safety reasons, and when you decrease your vehicle speed, the electronic differential re-engages to keep your drive stable.
What Is An Air Locker?
An Air Locker is a pressure-activated locking differential, paired with a source of pressurized air and electronic communications for controlling activation. When the lock mode is activated, the differential gears are prevented from rotating, thereby preventing the wheel shafts from turning apart from each other. Having both wheels connected to the rotational ring gear, the vehicle has maximum possible traction at all times.
Electric Lockers vs. Air Lockers – Factors To Compare
Here we’re going to compare some of the important factors regarding these two lockers to justify which one actually remains ahead. So, let’s start.
Working Mechanism
On an elevated platform inside of an airlock, you will come across the highly familiar components stored inside an open case. However, when the pneumatic pressure is released, a locking attachment slides forward, locking the gears together. This action converts an open differential into a spool.
It is necessary to supply pressurized air to the brakes of a vehicle for engagement and protection of the bike’s components. A switch on your vehicle dash activates a mechanism that supplies pressurized air to the pressure canister and circulates it through the air jack.
When the switch is engaged, the pressure that is stored in the canister travels via airlines to the differential. Until the tension is released, the collar inside the apparatus keeps the gears together.
On the other hand, E-lockers use an electric motor to create a helix. Inside an e-locker, you will see the magnet pulls two rollers apart. After that occurs, the ball bearings maintain them apart. The separation of these rollers pushes steel pins straight into the side of the differential, which in turn locks them together.
A blocker’s emplacement doesn’t necessitate an outside source of power, other than 12-volt power. This is an advantage to air lockers, however, which require both the 12-volt supply and the compressor. After the emplacement switch is flipped, a rate or degree of rotation will be made in order for the lock mechanisms to engage.
Compatibility
Many factory vehicles are equipped with sea locker differentials, as the manufacturers Toyota, Ford, GM, and Chrysler do. Often, this adds fuel to the air lockers and e-lockers a notion.
As some people have the choice to use e-lockers as factory equipment, the belief is that aftermarkets should use them as well. When circumstances arise that render these factory units faulty, the air locker camp has more ammunition.
Street Use
Dually locked differentials make certain that most of the wheels are powered by the steering wheel at the same rate. This, however, causes serious functionality issues because driving becomes difficult, given that the vehicle eats through the tires and leaves severe skid marks on the road.
Cost
Recalling how we brought up air lockers as having the advantage that they’re essentially functional out of the box, we’re adding that convenience also comes at a cost.
By the way, you must look at upgrading from a compressor to an onboard air compressor or carbon dioxide tank, as well as needing to put in the additional time and cost in parts and labor, and you may find yourself paying close to $1500 to update your carrier.
While it may be far more cost-effective to purchase e-lockers, you probably don’t have the indispensable skill set nor the equipment for handling critical differential repair activities.
Even if you’re tempted to try doing the work yourself, you will need the best course of action is to contact an expert automotive firm with high-level experience working on locking differentials for off-road vehicles.
Electric Lockers vs. Air Lockers – Which One Is Better For You?
Now, it’s time to make your decision. So, which one is for you, Air Locker or Electric Locker? Those who want to skip the hassle of air compressors may desire to use an e-locker because it’s easy and convenient.
An e-lock is simpler than air lockers, confirming its hours of operation since at times one must pierce it and reopen it to actually get to the locker. The only drawback of having an e-locker is the necessity of confirming it truly is open once you open it.
Some off-road enthusiasts may dislike the fact that their E-lockers do not have instant-locking differentials as well. E-Locker expenses are slightly more than air locker expenditures, but the values are very close.
Air lockers let you instantaneously lock the differential regardless of the conditions. It does not require more components than an E-locker, but there are components that can easily fit. Air compressors are an extremely helpful extra that you will need to place in order for them to operate appropriately.
The majority of individuals utilize air locker ARB, which can also give the dual-mode air supply. Having a compressor on board you now have the ability to inflate your tires or take pleasure in the utilization of air tools as well as pumping up your bath tank.
Air lockers may be more cumbersome and have more options because of the danger of ending an airline’s journey. With either type of lock, both locks are effectively meant for light-duty use.
They will lock or unlock the wheels when you want them to. However, for anyone who needs an extremely precise amount of turning and the rotational force is very low, one option will be superior over the other.
Final Words
Yes, the argument of Electric Lockers vs. air Lockers is on the rage, but both of them are top of their class. It’s just a matter of your preference and driving habit to pick one option from these two.
Read also: